The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was created in 1949 to help protect its member countries from treaties, especially during the Cold War. The United States has always been a major part of NATO, but now, some people think it might be time for America to leave. Even Donald Trump, the President of The United States, has been treatening to leave NATO. Now, there are strong arguements both for and against this idea, and it's important to consider both sides before deciding to consider both sides before deciding what's best for the country
One of the main reasons people think the U.S. should leave NATO is the cost. America spends way more money on defense than other NATO countries, and some argue that other NATO countries, and some argue that other nations aren't contributing their fair share. The U.S. is already reponsible for much of NATO's military power, so why should it continue paying billions of dollars to support other countries? Some believe that money could be better spent on things like education, helatcare, or fixing problems within the U.S. itself.
Another arguement for leaving NATO is that the U.S. has its own powerful military and doesn't necessarily need NATO's protection. The U.S. has strong alliances outside of NATO, and some believe that America should focus on is own defense instead of helping other countries with theirs. Plus, NATO was originally formed to deal with threats from the Soviet Union, which no longer exists. Is NATO even necessary anymore?
On the other hand, there are also good reasons to stay in NATO. One of the biggest reasons is that NATO provides security. If the U.S. were ever attacked, NATO allies are supposed to come to its defense. The same goes for when other NATO countries need help-having allies can make a country stronger. Leaving NATO could make America look weaker and might encourage countries like Russia or CHina to become more agressive. Would the U.S. be able to handle big global conflicts alone?
Another reason to stay in NATO is influence. Being part of NATO gives America a strong voice in international politics. If the U.S. left, it might lose some of its power and leadership in the world. Some people believe that being in NATO helps America keep peace and stablity in different parts of the world. Without NATO, could conflicts get worse?
Do you think America should leave NATO or stay?
Would leaving NATO make the country stronger or put it at risk?
Is NATO still useful, or is it outdated?
Should other countries be required to pay more if the U.S stays in?
https://history.state.gov/milestones/1945-1952/nato
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-44717074
https://theweek.com/news/world-news/955953/the-pros-and-cons-of-nato
Replies
I agree with you, even though America seems to have many alliances with other countries. NATO could still be helpful take down powerful threats in times of need especially if we were to go to war with a country like Russia.
I believe that the amount other countries should depend on their GDP or Gross Domestic Product. Which determines how many goods a country produces which in turn determines how much money a country makes. If a country makes more GDP, then they should pay more, but I feel like those who don't make as much shouldn't be required to pay as much, because statistically America is by far the leader in GDP enabling them to invest more into NATO.
I see your point on how much a country should contribute to NATO could be based on GDP. I agree it would make sense for weather nations like the US to invest more since they have more resources. However, this could be seen as a reason why the U.S should leave NATO. If America is always paying more while other countries don't contribute as much, it could seem to some people that the U.S is carrying too much of the smaller countries' burdens.
I really like the way you answered the question and I agree with you. I like the way you talked about the GDP and you explained it well. So it makes sense in what you are saying.
I think it could both put us at risk and strenghten us. As I mentioned before I think that if we were to leave NATO, then we would be less informed of world events and less able to help our allies. However the opportunities that would arise with the extended budget if we were to leave NATO would be astounding.
I think America should stay in NATO for many reasons. 1) I think that if we were to leave NATO we would lose trust from certain countries that kind of rely on our military strength. 2) I think that we as a country should not go back to isolationism as then we wouldn't have as much control and we wouldn't be as informed as to what's going on in the outside world.
I completely agree with you, NATO really helps with countries security and without them it would put us in a huge risk and a vulnerable state were we could be attacked by other nations. We also have many treaties with other nations and they really need our help. With us backing out of that it would look really suspicous and it would seem that we don't care about them anymore.
I think the U.S. should stay in NATO because although we do have the strongest military It still helps to be part of that group in times of war. And it doesn't make the U.S. as vulnerable to attack.
I think if the U.S. stays in nato then all the other countries should be required to pay more. So the U.S. isn't providing all the aid. And also I think It would be smart to state in NATO because if we leave we will be weaker and more vulnerable to attack.
I agrre with you, yes we do put our money in aid and military power but other countries should also come in and help pay some of the expenses. It would seem fair if all the nations would be able to pay a fair share to help each other.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
of 4 Next